1.1 Course-Level Design
Evaluation for 1.1a
Materials include a scope and sequence outlining the TEKS, ELPS, concepts, and knowledge taught in the course.
- The materials include a scope and sequence located in the Program Overview, which outlines the TEKS taught in each unit. For example, the grade 1 Fractions unit covers the TEKS 1.6(G) and 1.6(H).
- The Program Overview contains a Program Unit Map, an ELPS Map, and a Process Standards Map. Each section includes a rationale and progression for the entire year. The ELPS Map describes how the units incorporate the ELPS into instruction across the course. Teachers are provided with the specific ELPS written out on each lesson plan. For example, in the lesson titled "Models & Numbers Loop," the specific ELPS are listed in the "Language Standards" section. The ELPS listed include the following: "1(A) Use prior knowledge and experiences to understand meanings in English"; "4(C) Develop basic sight vocabulary, derive the meaning of environmental print, and comprehend English vocabulary and language structures used routinely in written classroom materials." Each unit begins with an overview that contains the lesson title, content standards, process skills, ELPS, and suggested days. For example, the grade 1 Numbers to 120 Overview instructs the teacher that the first lesson after the scaffold-back lesson will be called "Counting Collections, Part 2" and covers TEKS 1.5(B), 1.2(C), and K.2(B), Process Standards 1(A), 1(B), 1(C), and 1(E), as well as ELPS 2(A) and 3(B). The student expectations listed in the table are explicitly written out below it. If teachers are unfamiliar with ELPS 1(B), they will need to seek information beyond the program to understand it.
- The "Unit Rationale" section located in the Program Overview shows a clear alignment of concepts and knowledge in the unit and lesson progression. The "Grade 1, Unit 9 Rationale" from the Program Overview states that "the primary aim of this unit is to develop students' ability to collect data based on a specific question, organize it into a graph, and interpret the results."
1.1b
Materials include suggested pacing (pacing guide/calendar) to support effective implementation for various instructional calendars (e.g., varying numbers of instructional days – 165, 180, 210).
See Quality Review Evidence for this Indicator
Evaluation for 1.1b
Materials include suggested pacing (pacing guide/calendar) to support effective implementation for various instructional calendars (e.g., varying numbers of instructional days – 165, 180, 210).
- The "Unit Rationale" section includes pacing that would support an instructional calendar ranging from 145 to 210 days. The rationale includes a note to teachers stating that "each unit's schedule includes days for pre-assessments, re-teaching opportunities, scaffold-back lessons, scaffold-forward lessons, and unit assessments. When planning, materials provide guidance to consider the number of days on your instructional calendar and on adjusting as necessary." The materials include the "Unit Overview" and "Pacing Snapshot" sections, which list each unit and the suggested range of instructional days, respectively. For example, the materials suggest that grade 1, Unit 4: Time should last 12 to 15 days.
- The materials offer ways for teachers to transition lessons into workstations, allowing students to continue practicing skills throughout the year. The grade 1, Unit 6: Numbers to 120 materials include workstations such as "Ten More Connect Four" and "One More and One Less," which students can continue practicing throughout the year until they demonstrate mastery.
Evaluation for 1.1c
Materials include an explanation for the rationale of unit order as well as how concepts to be learned connect throughout the course.
- The materials recommend an intentional sequence of units that considers the connections between the concepts taught throughout the year. For example, as the Program Unit Map for grade 1 states, "Unit 1 begins with addition and subtraction concepts, which are embedded throughout the year. Students then explore geometry and move to fractions, where they use their spatial reasoning to partition 2D figures. Students then apply their understanding of halves to tell time to the nearest hour and half hour. This is followed by 'Addition & Subtraction, Part 2,' where students solve all problem types. Unit 6 engages students in early place value understandings with numbers up to 120. Then, they use skip counting strategies to count collections of coins and explore personal financial literacy concepts. Students finish the year exploring linear measurement and, finally, data analysis."
- The materials include a progression graphic on the Program Unit Map that visually shows how the concepts and knowledge connect to the skills and recurring topics across units. The Program Unit Map also contains a "Unit Rationale" section for each unit that explains how the unit connects to prior and future learning. As the rationale for grade 1, Unit 1: Addition and Subtraction, Part 1 states, "The unit aims to expose students to joining and separating change-unknown and provide opportunities to build their understanding of basic fact strategies, such as making ten and subtracting to ten. Students solve problems within twenty where 'regrouping' is not required. The work in this unit prepares students for Unit 5: Addition & Subtraction, Part 2, where students explore all the problem types and then apply basic fact strategies such as using ten and subtracting to a ten. Students continue to engage in activities."
- Each unit contains a "Content Map," which lists previously taught standards in the "Scaffold-Back" section, current grade level focal standards for the unit in the "Concept Development" section, and opportunities for extension in the "Scaffold-Forward" section. As the grade 1 Program Overview explains, "While students are engaged in the Concept Development phase of learning, some students need prior concepts reinforced, and others are ready for extensions. Scaffold-back and Scaffold-forward lessons provide guidance for teachers to easily differentiate to meet all students' needs." For example, as the grade 1 Content Map at the beginning of Unit 8: Measurement explains, "Students explore different ways objects and substances can be measured and use their reasoning skills to compare which has more or less of a given attribute" in the "Scaffold-Back" section, and how it extends to "more formal measuring tools to determine the length of an object to the nearest whole unit" in the "Scaffold-Forward" section.
Evaluation for 1.1d
Materials include guidance, protocols, and/or templates for unit and lesson internalization.
- The Implementation Support Guide includes detailed protocols for district mathematics leaders, instructional coaches, and teachers on internalizing the program. The grade 1 materials include templates and step-by-step instructions to create a "Year-at-a-Glance" for a school year with four or six grading periods.
- The grade 1 materials provide a template for creating a unit where teachers unpack the big ideas from it. For example, the Addition and Subtraction Unit-at-a-Glance template guides how to read through the unit overview and annotate findings such as manipulatives, models, vocabulary, misconceptions, and strategies within the unit. The Implementation Support Guide provides a pre-filled sample template that serves as an example that can be used during planning.
- This guide also provides a template for internalizing each unit by asking questions that promote deep thinking about the unit's content. The first part of the Unit Internalization Template is specific to the unit. For example, the template for grade 1, Unit 1: Addition & Subtraction, Part 1 asks "Why are addition and subtraction taught simultaneously throughout the unit instead of in isolation?" The second part of the template applies to all the units throughout the course. This section promotes deeper thinking of the content by asking questions like, "What might we do to differentiate for students who are having difficulty mastering the concepts throughout the unit?"
Evaluation for 1.1e
Materials include resources and guidance to support administrators and instructional coaches with implementing the materials as designed.
- The materials guide teachers, instructional coaches, and administrators in implementing the materials as designed through specific guidance included in the Program Overview. For example, the program components explain each piece of the units in detail. Every unit starts with a "Learning Progression" document. The "Learning Progression Content Map" visually shows the progression of standards within the unit and their connection to previously taught standards. The "Learning Progression Activity Map" illustrates how the content is covered through lessons, tasks, games, and workstations.
- Each lesson in the grade 1 program includes a lesson plan that lists the needed materials for the lesson, a "Lesson Scaffold" section that explains how to guide the students through the lesson, and a "Suggestion" section that offers methods to address common misconceptions as well as tips for the program's smooth implementation.
- The Implementation Support Guide provides guiding questions and a "Lesson Internalization Overview" section to help instructional coaches and teachers understand the materials and lesson components. This guide also includes an "Instructional Look Fors" document to guide teachers, instructional coaches, and administrators in implementing the lessons as designed. This document outlines six big things to look for regarding instruction for administrators and instructional coaches: "1. What is the role of the teacher and students? 2. How is the teacher promoting student discourse? 3. How is the teacher differentiating for all learners? 4. How are students engaged in the lesson? 5. How does the teacher check for understanding? 6. How is the teacher structuring the lesson?" The materials provide an "Instructional Look Fors Observation Form" to help teachers, coaches, and administrators set an area of focus for teacher growth in the program's implementation.
1.2 Unit-Level Design
Evaluation for 1.2a
Materials include comprehensive unit overviews that provide the background content knowledge and academic vocabulary necessary to effectively teach the concepts in the unit.
- The materials include a comprehensive overview of each unit. The overview for grade 1, Unit 1: Addition and Subtraction, Part 1 contains a section titled "Content Summary" that lists primary learning targets for the unit. Each topic is clearly defined, correlating with student expectations. This section informs the teacher about which skills build upon one other, where students may struggle, and which skills will be expanded on in future units.
- Each unit overview contains a section titled "Common Misconceptions." The overview for grade 1, Unit 1: Addition and Subtraction, Part 1 states, "students may confuse the addition and subtraction symbols as they develop their ability to represent problems using equations." This section helps build background content knowledge.
- Each unit overview contains a section titled "Vocabulary/Academic Language." This section lists terms to be used during instruction. Teachers are advised to "create a word wall."
- The materials connect previously learned concepts and strategies in each unit to current content. Each unit contains a content map that provides the background content knowledge and skills in the "Scaffold-Back" section necessary for success in the "Concept Development" section. The grade 1, Unit 4: Time Content Map explains that "students understand the continuous nature of time and can communicate the relative time of events using words such as yesterday, today, tomorrow, before, and after" as the prerequisite skills to tell time to the nearest half hour.
Evaluation for 1.2b
Materials contain supports for families in both Spanish and English for each unit with suggestions on supporting the progress of their student.
- The "Family/Caregiver Support" section in the materials provides family letters for each unit and some math games to be played at home. All support information provided is in English and Spanish. Each letter contains a section titled "In this unit, your Kindergartener will...," "Things that make you go hmmm...," and "Math Outside the Classroom."
- The grade 1, Unit 3: Fractions family letter tells families that their student will "partition 2D figures into two fair shares and describe the parts as halves, partition 2D figures into four fair shares and describe the parts as fourths and identify examples and non-examples of halves and fourths."
- The "Things that make you go hmmm…" section of grade 1, Unit 5: Addition and Subtraction, Part 2 family letter reminds families, "Focus on reading comprehension when reading story problems. This will help students understand the relationship between the numbers in the story problem."
- The "Math Outside the Classroom" section materials provide families with ideas for practicing concepts outside of the classroom. Grade 1, Unit 7: Money and Personal Financial Literacy family letter suggests that families "find a collection of coins and help [their] first grader count them." The letter also reminds parents that first graders do not count collections of coins involving quarters until grade 2.
- Grade 1, Unit 6: Numbers to 120 family letter provides a "Race to 120" game board for students and families to practice at home. This provides families with authentic ideas to extend math outside the classroom through literature connection and by using common household items to create hands-on experiences.
1.3 Lesson-Level Design
1.3a
Materials include comprehensive, structured, detailed lesson plans that include daily objectives, questions, tasks, materials, and instructional assessments required to meet the content and language standards of the lesson.
See Quality Review Evidence for this Indicator
Evaluation for 1.3a
Materials include comprehensive, structured, detailed lesson plans that include daily objectives, questions, tasks, materials, and instructional assessments required to meet the content and language standards of the lesson.
- The grade 1 materials include a comprehensive list of all materials, supplies, and preparation required to support instructional activities for each lesson. Each lesson includes the sections "Materials Needed" and "Preparation," which contain detailed information such as book titles, math manipulatives, tools, and other necessary materials required to meet the content and language standards of the lesson. The grade 1, Unit 1: Addition and Subtraction, Part 1 "Materials Needed" section for the lesson titled "Missing Cupcakes" informs teachers they will need to gather Pete the Cat and the Missing Cupcakes by Kimberly and James Dean, as well as supply one Cupcake Window Work Mat, ten two-color counters, one Missing Cupcakes Exit Ticket, and one pencil per student.
- The grade 1 materials include structured, detailed, step-by-step lesson plans that are easy to follow. These lesson plans are comprehensive and cover the span of expectations for the school year. In the grade 1, Unit 9: Data Analysis lesson titled "Using Tallies to Keep Track," the Content and Language Objective states that "students will collect data, organize the data using tallies, create a bar-type graph, and analyze the results." The lesson lists materials needed for this lesson: Tally Cat Keeps Track by Trudy Harris, twenty-five craft sticks per class, three plastic cups per class, one sticky note per student, one grid work mat per student, one dry-erase work map per student, one permanent marker (optional), one sheet of white paper per student (optional), as well as chart markers and one sheet of chart paper for teacher use. The lesson facilitation steps provide the teacher with step-by-step guidance to implement the lesson. For example, step one tells the teacher to "sit students in a circle and begin reading Tally Cat Keeps Track, stopping on pages 10-11." The lesson continues as the teacher directs students to notice how Tally Cat keeps track using tallies and asks what they notice about how the number ten is represented. The teacher hands out one craft stick to each student and asks questions such as "Which is your favorite color of these?" Students place their craft sticks next to their favorite-colored cup, then engage in a think-pair-share routine to discuss how they can organize the craft sticks. The lesson continues as the teacher and students work together to organize the data onto chart paper to create a bar-type graph.
- The grade 1 materials provide daily opportunities for formative assessment through teacher observation. For example, at the end of the Unit 6: Numbers to 120 lesson called "Shake and Compare," the teacher informally assesses students by observing students pour two-color counters out of a cup, record the number of red and yellow counters, and compare the two numbers by circling greater than, less than, or equal to on their recording sheets. The teacher listens for students to correctly compare the two numbers and explains how the double ten frames help them compare.
- The grade 1 materials provide opportunities for students to demonstrate proficiency more formally through exit tickets. In grade 1, Unit 3: Fractions lesson "Pattern Block Fractions," students use pattern blocks to explore the concept of partitioning shapes into halves and fourths. At the end of the activity, the students are given an exit ticket in which they partition a drawn hexagon into halves and fourths and explain how they know it has been partitioned into halves and fourths.
- The grade 1 materials include opportunities for students to practice language objectives in each lesson. For example, in the Unit 8: Measurement lesson "How Long?" Students use their language skills by explaining how they measured the length of various classroom objects using craft sticks.
Evaluation for 1.3b
Materials include a lesson overview outlining the suggested timing for each lesson component.
- The materials include the Implementation Support Guide. This guide includes suggested lesson component timing for different instructional situations. For example, if the teacher introduces new content, a new workstation, or a new partner activity, the guide advises the teacher on how to adjust their lesson timing. For new or continued content, the daily energizer will take five minutes, the mini lesson will take fifteen minutes, lesson closure will take five minutes, and workstations and small group instruction will take thirty-five to fifty-five minutes.
- The Implementation Support Guide provides a different lesson component timing If the lesson facilitation introduces a new workstation. When a new workstation is introduced, the daily energizer will take five minutes, the mini lesson (introduce a new workstation) will take fifteen minutes, practicing the new workstation will take twenty minutes, workstations and small group instruction will take fifteen to thirty-five minutes, and the lesson closure will take five minutes.
Evaluation for 1.3c
Materials include a lesson overview listing the teacher and student materials necessary to effectively deliver the lesson.
- The grade 1 materials provide two lists for each unit that include all the materials needed to teach the lessons in the unit. One list includes the required materials provided in the kit and is broken down into reusable print, reusable materials, and consumable materials. An additional list includes manipulatives, classroom supplies, consumable print, and trade books not included in the kit.
- The unit-level materials lists are not organized into teacher and student materials. All lessons include a "Materials Needed" section with a list of items needed for the lesson. Each material list at the lesson level states how many of the required materials are necessary. For example, the grade 1, Unit 9 lesson "Using Tallies to Keep Track" lists the book Tally Cat Keeps Track by Trudy Harris, twenty-five craft sticks per class, three plastic cups per class, one sticky note per student, one grid work mat per student, one dry erase work map per student, one permanent marker (optional), one sheet of white paper per student (optional), as well as chart markers and one sheet of chart paper for teacher use.
- Each lesson plan includes a "Preparation" section that informs teachers of any work that needs to be completed before the start of the lesson to deliver it effectively. For example, in the grade 1, Unit 8: Measurement lesson titled "Comparing Names," the materials instruct the teacher to "copy and cut enough rows from the name grids so each student has a row."
Evaluation for 1.3d
Materials include guidance on the effective use of lesson materials for extended practice (e.g., homework, extension, enrichment).
- All the grade 1 lesson plans include a section titled "Lesson Suggestions," which provides suggestions for scaffolding and extension. For example, the grade 1, Unit 9: Data Analysis lesson "The Change in My Pocket" suggests extending student learning by encouraging students to verbalize what they notice about the graph. The lesson includes the sentence stem "I have more ____ than..." to help students verbalize their thinking.
- The materials provide family letters for each unit that contain opportunities to review, apply new knowledge, and connect student learning to experiences beyond school. For example, Unit 3: Fractions family letter lists activities that can be done at home to help extend the lesson. One activity includes playing a game called "Fraction Bump" that students will have learned in class. The family letter includes a copy of the game board so students can have additional practice at home with their families.
- The materials provide opportunities for families to reinforce and review classroom learning. For example, the grade 1, Unit 8: Measurement family letter suggests, "Have your first grader use paperclips to measure the length of different household items. Have your first grader measure the same item with two different objects, such as paper clips and craft sticks, and discuss why the measurements were different."
- Family letters also provide opportunities for families to help their students make connections between the math that they are learning in the classroom and math in the real world. For example, the Unit 7: Money and Personal Financial Literacy family letter encourages students to go to the store with their family and, as they shop, discuss whether the purchased items are wanted or needed, and why.